|
If
there is any doubt that journalists are an endangered species,
look at the Trillanes Episode.
Better
still are the criminals: they are arrested with warrants of
arrest issued by the Courts before detention. In America,
the Court ordered a suspect released because the cops chained
him to his bed while they visited the judge to prepare the
Warrant of Arrest.
Better
still are the criminals: only the hardened ones dying to escape
or capable of violence, are handcuffed on the way to jail.
Better still are the criminals: they are read the Miranda
Doctrine: the right to make one phone call (probably to a
lawyer) before one can be arrested.
Better
still are the criminals because they are just bodily lodged
to jail - his tools of the trade, his business, his factory
- are all left intact.
We
all saw how Government treated media after the Manila Peninsula
incident last Thursday. Why was that so?
Perhaps
it was the Government's way of suggesting to media people
that they are in the wrong industry? Perhaps it was Government's
way of intimidating media that it (Government) can do its
fancy best and media just have to grin and bear it?
As
part of media, the CHRONICLE condemns in the strongest terms
possible the harassment and violation of human rights of media
men after the Trillanes Episode.
The
journalists were dumped like handcuffed pigs in the bus for
the slaughter or "processing" inside the military
camp - not seeing the warrants for their arrests and the cause
of their detention, not allowed to do the Miranda Drill and
some of their broadcast equipment and documents confiscated.
The
fact that the media men were later released does not obliterate
the reality of the illegality and inhumanity of their earlier
detention. The "processing" could have been done
at the Manila Pen itself after the incident. The ineptitude
of the authorities to arrest the elusive Houdini by the name
of Captain Faeldon of the Hundred Disguises is not media's
fault.
Before
GMA left for Europe, she had cautioned her men not to "unnecessarily
rile media. Be circumspect. We are not at war with them."
It
is one of the president's sobering moments of realization
- that media was out there just to do its job. As Maria Ressa
of ABS-CBN said: "We merely covered a news event to show
to the world what happened." Ces Drilon TV Reporter said:
"A press conference was called, we had to attend."
The
fact that media had some half-baked information about the
Trillanes Plan (earlier) is nothing but a sign of a failure
of intelligence of the Military. Even the fact that some media
men reserved rooms at the Manila Peninsula does not make them
accomplices of Trillanes' alleged crime. That a TV network
was able to set up its TV monitors in quick tempo is not a
manifestation of support of the mutiny but a die-hard commitment
to score a scoop as good journalists would always want.
As
an aside, TV anchors Pinky Webb was not fully "made up"
as she is wont to do and Ces Drilon wore a three and a half
inch clog footwear to cover the event. Are these not circumstances
that instead suggest that they knew nothing about the details
of the Trillanes Plan?
In
conflict situations, like war-torn Iraq, for example, the
danger posed to the lives of both soldiers and media men is
the same. Scores of media men, in fact, died chronicling the
atrocities in the Vietnam War.
Media
men offer their lives in conflict situations to portray the
truth - yet when they die they are just considered collateral
damage, a tragic statistic in the war and are never given
medals by Government for heroism. That only proves that Government
recognizes they are just doing their jobs so they need no
adulation.
That
being so, why were they then arrested? If indeed they were
"obstructing justice" why were they released from
the military camp after the "processing". Why is
the contemplated charge of "obstructing justice"
now a favorite government afterthought?
But
if Government thinks it can intimidate media by using Marcosian
tactics, it can try its luck further.
Threats
and harm's way are part of the media man's territory. Those
media men who are afraid to die with their pens in their hand
can stay home and play the game of chess. It is a harmless
game but thought-provoking, at least.
The
National Press Club (NPC) had already filed charges against
the DILG and the PNP before the Commission on Human Rights
(CHR). And rightly so - before the temporary handcuffs turn
into days of incarceration or years in the bartolina for media
men - without media even knowing what the charges are.
Impatient
with media's attack on Bush's war involvement in Iraq, pointed
questions have been asked of media " Are you an American
first or are you a journalist?" Or as Bush would categorize
the world (and media) into black and white by saying "You
are either with us or you are with terrorists."
Journalism
- whether here or in America - should never yield to that
kind of patriotism.
It
is a crude kind of patriotism that abandons moral responsibility.
That kind of patriotism leads people to support brutal policies
and to hide the truth from public view.
Therefore
the Fourth Estate - for it to be truly useful to society -
must be left alone to do its mandate to the public good.
It
is only when media seeks the truth, finds the truth and tell
it as it is will it become patriotic. Not anything less than
that - even though it may "appear" patriotic. They
are mere appearances.
For Comments: email to
bingo_dejaresco@boholchronicle.com Or editor@boholchronicle.com
|